Counting down...
With just under 3 hours (ET) to the pre-Olympic trade deadline, players across the league are anxiously keeping one eye on the clock, the other on their cell phones.
Earlier today, Ottawa shipped defender Alex Picard and a 2nd round pick to Carolina for Matt Cullen, the first of many moves expected to go down for the re-building Hurricanes.
Last night, Montreal shipped a 2nd round pick on 2011 to Florida for C Dom Moore. I couldn't help but chuckle at this deal. It seems John Ferguson Jr.'s crowning achievement as GM of the Leafs was plucking the plucky C off the waiver wire from the Minnesota Wild, ironically enabling incoming GM Brian Burke to flip him to Buffalo at last year's deadline for...you guessed it, a 2nd round pick.
On its face, neither of these deals are earth shattering, but I do selfishly have a Spockian eyebrow raised at the return for the two most recent players dealt in the NHL and how it impacts what the blue and white may fetch for some of their expiring contracts - Alexei Ponikarovsky and Lee Stempniak first and foremost amongst them.
Let's have a look at the stats:
Recently Traded Rental Players:
Dominic Moore
GP G A PIM +/-
48 8 9 35 -7
Matt Cullen
GP G A PIM +/-
60 12 28 26 E
Maple Leafs Available:
Alexei Ponikarovsky
GP G A PIM +/-
60 19 22 44 +5
Lee Stempniak
GP G A PIM +/-
60 14 15 18 -8
Moore garnered a 2nd round pick in 2011, while Cullen received a serviceable defender and a 2nd round pick in the 2010 entry draft.
Both scenarios are as close to 'apples to apples' comparisons as I can think.
If you apply similar values for the Leafs available, you may consider Lee Stempniak worthy of a future 2nd rounder - but you have to take into consideration a couple of factors:
- -Stempniak's $2.5 million cap hit (pro-rated) makes him a tougher deadline acquisition to fit into a team's existing salary structure.
- -Stempniak has similar numbers to Moore, however has played in 12 additional games this season.
Turning attention to Alexei Ponikarovsky, here is where I think the true value lays, and I believe a better return should be expected than what we saw in the Cullen deal:
- -Younger
- -Bigger
- -Attractive salary
- -More goals
- -VERY defensively responsible
...these are obvious factors considering the big Ukraine's value.
With PIT rumoured to have interest, look for a player (Kennedy, Dupuis?) and a second round pick + coming back.
In Stempniak's case, I think the most Leafs Nation can hope for is a 3rd rounder.
Time will tell - I'll be back with more if the Leafs make any moves.
Tha begs the question: What would you do?
MD27
|